claude-plugins/fiction-assistance/commands/analyze/check-continuity.md

description, allowed-tools

description	allowed-tools
Check for plot holes and character consistency	Write(40 - Generated/Analysis/continuity-report.md)

You are performing continuity analysis for the Universalis story to identify plot holes, character inconsistencies, and world-building contradictions.

Manuscript: ./00 - Manuscript/

Objectives:

1. Character consistency checking across all appearances
2. World-building validation for technology, species, locations
3. Plot hole identification in story logic
4. Relationship tracking for character interactions
5. Knowledge tracking for what characters know when

Continuity Analysis Areas:

1. Character Consistency

For each character, verify:

• Personality traits remain consistent across scenes
• Physical descriptions don't contradict
• Knowledge and abilities progress logically
• Relationships develop consistently
• Speech patterns match established voice
• Motivations align with established goals

2. World-Building Consistency

Check for contradictions in:

• Technology capabilities and limitations
• Species characteristics and behaviors
• Location descriptions and geography
• Political structures and relationships
• Historical events and timelines
• Rules of the universe (physics, magic, etc.)

3. Plot Logic Validation

Identify potential issues:

• Character knowledge - knowing things they shouldn't
• Information flow - how characters learn important facts
• Cause and effect - events leading logically to consequences
• Problem resolution - solutions matching established capabilities
• Motivation clarity - character actions matching their goals

4. Relationship Dynamics

Track consistency in:

• Character interactions over time
• Relationship development following logical progression
• Conflict resolution between characters
• Alliance formations and betrayals
• Family relationships and their evolution

Continuity Report:

Generate detailed analysis at ./40 - Generated/Analysis/continuity-report.md:

# Continuity Analysis Report

*Generated: {{current_date}}*

## Executive Summary
- **Continuity Issues Found**: {{total_issues}}
- **Character Inconsistencies**: {{character_issues}}
- **World-Building Problems**: {{worldbuilding_issues}}
- **Plot Logic Gaps**: {{plot_issues}}
- **Critical Issues**: {{critical_count}} (major plot holes)
- **Minor Issues**: {{minor_count}} (small inconsistencies)

## Character Consistency Analysis

### {{Character Name}}
**Consistency Score**: {{score}}/10

#### Personality Traits
- **Established traits**: {{list_established_traits}}
- **Inconsistent moments**: {{list_inconsistencies_with_chapter_refs}}
- **Character growth**: {{note_legitimate_development_vs_inconsistency}}

#### Physical Description
- **Established appearance**: {{physical_description_summary}}
- **Contradictions found**: {{list_description_conflicts}}

#### Knowledge Progression
- **What they know when**: {{knowledge_timeline}}
- **Information gaps**: {{unexplained_knowledge_gains}}
- **Knowledge inconsistencies**: {{impossible_knowledge_situations}}

#### Relationship Consistency
- **With {{other_character}}**: {{relationship_development_analysis}}
- **Interaction patterns**: {{consistent_vs_inconsistent_interactions}}

[Repeat for each major character]

## World-Building Consistency

### Technology Systems
{{technology_consistency_analysis}}

### Species Characteristics  
{{species_consistency_analysis}}

### Location Descriptions
{{location_consistency_analysis}}

### Political/Social Structures
{{political_consistency_analysis}}

## Plot Logic Analysis

### Information Flow Issues
{{information_flow_problems}}

### Cause and Effect Problems
{{cause_effect_inconsistencies}}

### Resolution Logic
{{solution_consistency_analysis}}

### Motivation Clarity
{{character_motivation_inconsistencies}}

## Critical Continuity Issues

### Major Plot Holes
{{list_major_plot_holes_with_details}}

### Character Knowledge Problems
{{list_knowledge_inconsistencies}}

### World-Building Contradictions
{{list_world_contradictions}}

## Minor Inconsistencies

### Description Variations
{{minor_description_inconsistencies}}

### Dialogue Style Variations
{{minor_voice_inconsistencies}}

### Detail Contradictions
{{minor_detail_conflicts}}

## Relationship Dynamics Analysis

### Character Relationship Map
{{relationship_consistency_by_pair}}

### Relationship Development Issues
{{relationship_logic_problems}}

### Unexplained Relationship Changes
{{sudden_relationship_shifts}}

## Recommendations

### Critical Fixes Needed
{{prioritized_list_of_major_fixes}}

### Continuity Improvements
{{suggestions_for_minor_fixes}}

### Tracking Suggestions
{{recommendations_for_future_continuity_maintenance}}

## Continuity Strengths

### Well-Maintained Elements
{{list_consistent_story_elements}}

### Strong Character Development
{{well_developed_character_arcs}}

### Solid World-Building
{{consistent_world_elements}}

## Analysis Methodology

### Sources Analyzed
- **Character Cards**: {{character_cards_analyzed}}
- **Chapter Scenes**: {{scenes_analyzed}}
- **Event Cards**: {{events_analyzed}}
- **Relationship Data**: {{relationships_tracked}}

### Consistency Metrics
- **Cross-Reference Points**: {{cross_reference_points}}
- **Character Appearances**: {{total_character_appearances}}
- **World-Building Elements**: {{worldbuilding_elements_tracked}}

---
Generated by Claude Code continuity analysis for Universalis writing project.

Analysis Methodology:

1. Character trait mapping across all appearances
2. Knowledge state tracking for each character through time
3. World-building element cataloging from all sources
4. Cross-referencing descriptions and capabilities
5. Timeline correlation with character actions and knowledge
6. Relationship evolution tracking between characters
7. Logic chain validation for plot developments

Issue Classification:

Critical Issues

• Major plot holes affecting story logic
• Character actions contradicting established personality
• Impossible knowledge or ability situations
• World-building rules violated

Minor Issues

• Small description variations
• Slight dialogue inconsistencies
• Detail contradictions that don't affect plot
• Minor timeline discrepancies

Validation Approach:

1. Evidence-based analysis using specific chapter references
2. Pattern recognition for consistent vs. inconsistent elements
3. Development vs. contradiction distinguishing growth from error
4. Context consideration for apparent inconsistencies
5. Prioritized recommendations for fixing issues

Output Requirements:

• Fixed filename: ./40 - Generated/Analysis/continuity-report.md
• Character-by-character analysis with specific examples
• World-building consistency evaluation
• Prioritized issue list with chapter references
• Actionable recommendations for improvement

IMPORTANT: Distinguish between legitimate character development and actual inconsistencies. Provide specific chapter references for all identified issues.