claude-plugins/fiction-assistance/commands/analyze/check-voice.md

description, allowed-tools

description	allowed-tools
Analyze character voice consistency and dialogue patterns	Write(40 - Generated/Analysis/voice-analysis.md)

You are performing character voice analysis for the Universalis story to ensure dialogue consistency and distinctive character voices.

Objectives:

1. Voice pattern analysis for each character across all appearances
2. Dialogue consistency checking against established character voice
3. Speech pattern identification and distinctiveness assessment
4. Voice development tracking over story progression
5. Dialogue quality evaluation for authenticity and character fit

Voice Analysis Areas:

1. Speech Pattern Analysis

For each character, analyze:

• Vocabulary choice (formal/informal, technical/simple, unique phrases)
• Sentence structure (short/long, complex/simple, fragmented/complete)
• Rhythm and flow (clipped speech, flowing dialogue, interruptions)
• Emotional expression patterns (how they show anger, joy, fear, etc.)
• Cultural/background influences on speech patterns

2. Character-Specific Voice Elements

• Catchphrases and repeated expressions
• Professional terminology usage patterns
• Regional/cultural dialects or speech markers
• Generational speech patterns (age-appropriate language)
• Personality manifestation in dialogue (confidence, humor, formality)

3. Dialogue Consistency Tracking

• Voice maintenance across different scenes and emotional states
• Stress response patterns in dialogue under pressure
• Character growth reflected appropriately in speech evolution
• Relationship dynamics affecting speech patterns with different characters

4. Distinctiveness Assessment

• Character voice uniqueness - can you identify speaker without tags?
• Overlap detection - characters sounding too similar
• Authentic characterization - dialogue matching personality and background
• Memorable speech - distinctive and engaging dialogue patterns

Voice Analysis Report:

Generate comprehensive analysis at 40 - Generated/Analysis/voice-analysis.md:

# Character Voice Analysis Report

*Generated: {{current_date}}*

## Overview
Analysis of character voice consistency, distinctiveness, and development across all appearances in Universalis.

## Executive Summary
- **Characters Analyzed**: {{character_count}}
- **Voice Consistency Score**: {{overall_consistency_score}}/10
- **Distinctiveness Score**: {{overall_distinctiveness_score}}/10
- **Issues Identified**: {{total_voice_issues}}

## Character Voice Profiles

### {{Character Name}}
**Voice Consistency**: {{consistency_score}}/10 | **Distinctiveness**: {{distinctiveness_score}}/10

#### Established Voice Pattern
- **Speaking Style**: {{speaking_style_description}}
- **Vocabulary Level**: {{vocabulary_assessment}}
- **Sentence Structure**: {{sentence_pattern_description}}
- **Emotional Expression**: {{emotional_expression_pattern}}
- **Signature Elements**: {{unique_speech_elements}}

#### Representative Dialogue Examples
{{most_characteristic_dialogue_samples_with_chapter_refs}}

#### Voice Consistency Analysis
- **Consistent Elements**: {{consistently_maintained_voice_elements}}
- **Inconsistent Moments**: {{dialogue_inconsistencies_with_chapter_refs}}
- **Character Growth**: {{legitimate_voice_evolution_vs_inconsistency}}

#### Voice Development Over Time
{{voice_evolution_analysis_across_story_arc}}

#### Relationship Voice Variations
- **With {{other_character}}**: {{voice_changes_in_this_relationship}}
- **In formal settings**: {{formal_voice_analysis}}
- **Under stress**: {{stress_voice_patterns}}

[Repeat for each major character]

## Cross-Character Analysis

### Voice Distinctiveness Matrix
| Character | Distinctiveness | Similar To | Unique Elements |
|-----------|----------------|------------|-----------------|
{{character_distinctiveness_comparison_table}}

### Voice Overlap Issues
{{characters_who_sound_too_similar}}

### Dialogue Tag Dependency
Characters requiring dialogue tags for identification:
{{characters_needing_better_voice_distinction}}

## Dialogue Quality Assessment

### Authenticity Analysis
- **Age-Appropriate Speech**: {{age_appropriate_assessment}}
- **Background Consistency**: {{background_voice_consistency}}
- **Cultural Authenticity**: {{cultural_speech_accuracy}}
- **Professional Terminology**: {{technical_language_appropriateness}}

### Emotional Range Analysis
{{emotional_expression_variety_and_authenticity}}

### Conversation Flow Analysis
{{dialogue_naturalness_and_flow_assessment}}

## Voice Consistency Issues

### Major Inconsistencies
{{significant_voice_breaks_with_specific_examples}}

### Minor Variations
{{small_inconsistencies_that_could_be_improved}}

### Character Growth vs. Inconsistency
{{legitimate_development_vs_actual_voice_problems}}

## Dialogue Strengths

### Most Distinctive Voices
{{characters_with_strongest_voice_identity}}

### Best Character Interactions
{{most_effective_dialogue_scenes}}

### Memorable Dialogue
{{most_quotable_or_character_defining_lines}}

## Improvement Recommendations

### Voice Strengthening
{{suggestions_for_making_voices_more_distinctive}}

### Consistency Improvements
{{specific_fixes_for_voice_inconsistencies}}

### Dialogue Enhancement
{{suggestions_for_improving_dialogue_quality}}

## Voice Guidelines for Future Writing

### {{Character Name}} Voice Guidelines
{{specific_writing_guidelines_for_this_character}}

[Guidelines for each major character]

### General Dialogue Best Practices
{{overall_dialogue_writing_recommendations}}

## Technical Analysis

### Dialogue Distribution
- **Most Dialogue**: {{character_with_most_lines}} ({{word_count}} words)
- **Dialogue Density**: {{dialogue_to_narrative_ratio_by_character}}
- **Scene Presence**: {{character_scene_participation_rates}}

### Voice Complexity Metrics
{{analysis_of_voice_sophistication_and_development}}

## Analysis Methodology

### Data Sources
- **Character Cards**: {{character_cards_analyzed}}
- **Chapter Scenes**: {{scenes_with_dialogue_analyzed}}
- **Dialogue Samples**: {{total_dialogue_lines_analyzed}}

### Voice Markers Tracked
{{list_of_voice_elements_analyzed}}

### Consistency Evaluation Criteria
{{methodology_for_assessing_voice_consistency}}

---
Generated by Claude Code voice analysis for Universalis writing project.

Analysis Methodology:

1. Dialogue extraction from all chapters by character
2. Pattern recognition for speech characteristics
3. Consistency mapping across character appearances
4. Comparative analysis between characters for distinctiveness
5. Development tracking for voice evolution
6. Quality assessment against character background and personality
7. Specific example identification for both strengths and issues

Voice Elements to Track:

Linguistic Patterns

• Word choice preferences (simple vs. complex vocabulary)
• Sentence length and structure preferences
• Use of contractions, slang, formal language
• Technical terminology usage patterns

Character-Specific Elements

• Catchphrases and repeated expressions
• Cultural/regional speech markers
• Professional jargon appropriate to character background
• Age and education level reflected in speech

Emotional Expression

• How each character expresses different emotions
• Stress response patterns in dialogue
• Humor expression (if applicable)
• Authority or submission patterns in speech

Issue Classification:

Major Voice Issues

• Character sounding completely different in different scenes
• Dialogue that contradicts established character background
• Multiple characters sounding identical
• Inappropriate language for character's background/age

Minor Voice Issues

• Slight vocabulary inconsistencies
• Occasional lapses in established speech patterns
• Missing opportunities for character-specific expressions
• Dialogue that's generic rather than character-specific

Output Requirements:

• Fixed filename: 40 - Generated/Analysis/voice-analysis.md
• Character-by-character detailed voice profiles
• Cross-character distinctiveness analysis
• Specific examples with chapter references
• Actionable guidelines for future dialogue writing

IMPORTANT: Provide specific dialogue examples for all assessments. Distinguish between legitimate character development and actual voice inconsistencies. Include positive examples of strong voice work alongside areas for improvement.